Sell Your House Fast in Brookhaven, NY

Get a Fair Cash Offer in 24 Hours • We Buy Houses in All 50+ Brookhaven Hamlets

Brookhaven is New York’s largest town, and we understand that selling property here comes with unique challenges. Whether you’re in Rocky Point, Port Jefferson, Centereach, or Mastic, we buy houses throughout all Brookhaven hamlets. Since 1999, we’ve helped Suffolk County families sell their homes quickly and fairly, from waterfront properties to inland homes needing repairs.

26 Years in Suffolk

Serving Brookhaven since 1999

All 50+ Hamlets

Rocky Point to Mastic Beach

★★★★★ Google Reviews

Top Rated Cash Buyer

Waterfront Experts

Sound, Bay & Fire Island properties

Local Market Reality

We Know Brookhaven Real Estate

Brookhaven is massive (531 sq miles). Selling in Shoreham is different than Mastic. We don't use generic pricing; we value your home based on its specific hamlet.

486k Residents 50+ Hamlets 2 Distinct Shorelines

North Shore

Rocky Point, Shoreham, Port Jeff

$600K - $1.5M+

Central

Centereach, Selden, Medford

$400K - $600K

South Shore

Mastic Beach, Shirley, Moriches

$300K - $550K

How to Sell Your Brookhaven House for Cash: 3 Simple Steps

Selling a house in Brookhaven shouldn't take months. Our process gets you from first contact to closing in as little as 7-14 days.

1

Contact Us & Share Details
(5 Minutes)

Call 516-605-3001 or fill out our form. We will have a friendly chat about your property. We won't pressure you or judge your home's condition at all. What We Discuss:
  • Which hamlet (Rocky Point? Mastic?)
  • Property condition & challenges
  • Your ideal timeline
Day 1: 10 Min Call
2

Get Your Fair Cash Offer
(Same Day)

We'll visit quickly to verify details and present a fair, no-obligation cash offer based on local Brookhaven market data, ensuring you get the best value possible. Our Evaluation Includes:
  • North vs. South Shore location
  • Recent sales in YOUR hamlet
  • Current condition & repairs needed
Days 1-2: Receive Offer
3

Choose Date & Get Paid
(7-30 Days)

You pick the closing date. We can close in 7-14 days or wait up to 60 days if needed. We handle everything from start to finish for you. The Finish Line:
  • We coordinate title & paperwork
  • You pay ZERO costs or fees
  • Funds wired immediately
Day 7+: You Choose Date

Types of Brookhaven Properties We Buy

Single-Family Homes

Rocky Point to Mastic Beach, any condition, any hamlet.

Multi-Family Homes

Long Island Sound, Great South Bay, or Fire Island access. We understand flood zones.

All Property Types

2-4 units throughout Brookhaven. Tenants in place? We handle it.

Why Brookhaven Families Choose Cash Sales

See how selling for cash compares to the traditional process in Brookhaven.

Factor Traditional Agent Sale Selling to Us Best Choice
Timeline 3-6 months average 7-14 days typically
Repairs Usually required None, buy as-is
Commissions 5-6% ($30k-$45k on $600K) Zero
Closing Costs Seller pays We cover
Showings Multiple weekly One visit
Waterfront Challenges Flood insurance issues We handle
Hamlet Knowledge Generic pricing Hamlet-specific offers
Financing Risk 20-30% fall through None — Cash

Ready to Sell Your Brookhaven Home?

Get a fair, no-obligation cash offer in 24 hours. We buy in all 50+ Brookhaven hamlets.

Get My Cash Offer Now
Luxury Queens House

Common Brookhaven Situations We Handle

Every hamlet, every situation. Here's how we help Brookhaven homeowners facing unique challenges across Long Island.

Waterfront Properties

Selling waterfront on the Sound or Bay? Flood insurance, storm damage, and buyer financing make these sales complex. We buy waterfront as-is.

Learn More

Inherited Properties

Inherited a home in Brookhaven but live out of state? Avoid the hassle of 531-square-mile drives for maintenance and showings.

Learn More

Foreclosure Prevention

Behind on mortgage in Brookhaven? Sell before auction, protect your credit, and move forward with dignity.

Learn More

Older Homes Need Repairs

Many Brookhaven homes are 40-60+ years old and need updates. Traditional buyers walk away. We buy as-is.

Learn More

Rental Property Issues

Tired of managing rentals across Brookhaven's 531 square miles? We buy tenant-occupied properties.

Learn More

Job Relocation

Relocating out of Suffolk County? Close in 7-14 days and move without stress.

Learn More

Facing One of These Situations?

We buy Brookhaven homes in any condition, any hamlet, any situation.

Yes, I Want My Cash Offer

Why Brookhaven Homeowners Choose Us

We're not just another cash buyer, we're Brookhaven specialists.

We Understand the Size

At 531 square miles, Brookhaven is massive. Selling in Shoreham is different from selling in Mastic. We price based on hamlet-specific data.

Precise Valuation Not generic algorithms

North Shore Experts

We specialize in the premium waterfront market along the Long Island Sound (Rocky Point, Shoreham, Port Jeff). We understand premium pricing.

Typical Price Range $600K - $1.5M+

South Shore Experts

Deep knowledge of Great South Bay communities like Mastic Beach & Shirley. We understand Fire Island access and boating rights value.

Typical Price Range $350K - $700K

Flood & Storm Ready

We buy properties in flood zones or with storm damage. Traditional buyers often run from high insurance costs—we understand them.

We Buy As-Is FEMA Zones Accepted

50+ Hamlet Coverage

We buy throughout ALL Brookhaven hamlets. Other buyers stick to "popular" areas, but we know the entire town inside out.

No Hamlet Too Remote From Mt. Sinai to Manorville

Suffolk Integration

We don't just know Brookhaven—we know how it fits into Suffolk real estate. We understand town codes, regulations, and legalization issues.

Full Compliance Handling all paperwork

We Buy Houses Throughout All Brookhaven Hamlets

All 50+ Communities • From the Sound to the Bay

North Shore

  • Rocky Point
  • Shoreham
  • Wading River
  • Port Jefferson Station
  • Setauket
  • Stony Brook
  • Lake Grove

Central

  • Centereach
  • Selden
  • Farmingville
  • Holtsville
  • Medford
  • Coram
  • Lake Ronkonkoma

South Shore

  • Mastic
  • Mastic Beach
  • Shirley
  • East Moriches
  • Center Moriches
  • Manorville
  • Yaphank

More Hamlets

  • Miller Place
  • Bellport
  • Ridge
  • Patchogue
  • Middle Island
  • Blue Point
  • Sound Beach

And 30+ More Hamlets

From Miller Place to Bellport, from Ridge to Patchogue—if it's in the Town of Brookhaven, we buy there.

See All Areas We Serve

We Cover Every Part of Brookhaven

Don't see your hamlet listed? We buy throughout the entire 531-square-mile town. Call 516-605-3001 to discuss your property.

Get My Cash Offer Now No obligation. 100% Free.

Real Brookhaven Examples

Scenario 1

Inherited 3-Family in Jamaica

The Problem

Four siblings inherited a multi-family home in Centereach. Two wanted to keep it, two wanted to sell. The property needed $80K in repairs, and tenants were paying below-market rent.

Our Solution

We made a cash offer accounting for deferred maintenance. All four siblings received equal proceeds, and we closed in 21 days with no repairs needed.

Scenario 2

Waterfront in Rocky Point

The Problem

Owner had a Long Island Sound waterfront property with flood damage. High insurance costs scared away traditional buyers. Property sat on market 8 months.

Our Solution

We bought as-is, understanding flood zones and storm damage. Closed in 14 days. Owner avoided another insurance renewal.

What Long Island Homeowners Say

5.0
Based on 5 Reviews
Google Rating

Eli Weinstock 3 years ago

"We needed to sell our home quickly for a work related move. Our biggest fear was having to sell at a discount. Luckily the team got us top dollar, and closed in 7 days. Highly recommended."

Kathryn Frasier May 28, 2025

"I was skeptical, but they made the process so easy. Got a good price, and everything went smoothly."

Marie Theriot May 20, 2025

"Selling my house was never easier. 123 We Buy House was transparent, fair, and quick. Would definitely recommend."

Michael Kelsey May 14, 2025

"I needed to sell fast and 123 We Buy House made it happen. Great experience."

Jordan Jr Homeowner

"The team was professional and responsive. 123 We Buy House made selling my home so simple. I didn’t have to worry about anything."

Brann Stacy Homeowner

"Amazing service! I sold my house to 123 We Buy House, and it was such a stress-free experience. They handled everything."

Frequently Asked Questions: Selling Your Brookhaven Home

We've answered hundreds of questions from Brookhaven homeowners.

How fast can I sell my house in Brookhaven?

We can close in as little as 7-14 days. Unlike traditional sales that take 3-6 months, our all-cash purchase eliminates financing delays, inspections, and appraisals. You choose the closing date that works for you.

Do you buy waterfront properties on the Sound or Bay?

Yes! We specialize in waterfront properties. We understand flood zones, insurance costs, storm damage, and erosion issues. Whether your property is on Long Island Sound (north shore) or Great South Bay (south shore), we buy as-is.

Which Brookhaven hamlets do you serve?

All 50+ hamlets throughout the entire 531-square-mile town. From Rocky Point to Mastic Beach, Centereach to Port Jefferson, Selden to Shirley. If it's in the Town of Brookhaven, we buy there.

How much will you offer for my Brookhaven property?

We make fair offers based on recent sales in YOUR specific hamlet, the property's condition, and whether it's waterfront or inland. North Shore waterfront commands different pricing than central Brookhaven properties. We show you the comparable sales and explain our offer transparently.

Our typical offers are 70-80% of After Repair Value (ARV). We're honest about this because we handle all repairs and carrying costs.

Can I sell my house if it needs major repairs?

Absolutely. We buy houses in any condition throughout Brookhaven. Roof damage, foundation issues, outdated systems, flood damage, fire damage—we handle it all. You don't spend a dime on repairs.

What if my property has tenants?

We buy tenant-occupied properties throughout Brookhaven. Whether you have good tenants, problematic tenants, or rent-controlled situations, we take over the landlord responsibilities. No evictions needed.

Do you buy properties in flood zones?

Yes. Many Brookhaven waterfront properties are in flood zones (especially Sound and Bay areas). We understand FEMA flood maps, insurance requirements, and storm damage. Traditional buyers struggle with flood zone financing—we buy with cash.

Are there any fees when selling to you?

Zero fees. No commissions (save 5-6%), no closing costs (save 2-3%), no repair costs, no cleaning costs. The offer we make is what you receive at closing.

How do you calculate offers for different hamlets?

We use hamlet-specific comparable sales. A home in Shoreham is priced differently than one in Farmingville. We analyze recent sales in YOUR specific hamlet, adjust for waterfront vs. inland, and factor in condition.

Can you close quickly if I'm relocating?

Yes. If you're relocating for work and need to close in 7-14 days, we can accommodate that. We can also wait 30-60 days if you need time to move. You control the timeline.

Do you buy multi-family properties in Brookhaven?

Yes. We buy 2-4 unit multi-family properties throughout Brookhaven. Whether occupied or vacant, we can handle the complexity of multiple units and tenants.

What happens after I accept your offer?

We open a transaction with a local Suffolk County title company. They handle all paperwork, ensure clear title, and coordinate the closing. You sign the deed, receive your funds immediately (wire or check), and hand over the keys. That's it.

Can I sell part of the year if I live out of state?

Yes. Many Brookhaven property owners live out of state or out of the country. We handle remote closings through title companies and can coordinate everything via phone, email, and DocuSign if needed.

Will you buy my property if it has code violations?

Yes. Town of Brookhaven code violations, open permits, certificate of occupancy issues, we buy properties with these challenges and resolve them after closing.

How is this different from listing with an agent?

Traditional Agent
Selling to Us
3-6 month timeline
7-14 day timeline
5-6% commission ($30K+ on $600K)
Zero commission
Repairs required
No repairs (as-is)
Multiple showings
One visit
Financing contingencies
Guaranteed cash
Deals fall through
We close for certain

About 123 We Buy House: Serving Brookhaven Since 1999

We're a family-owned business that's been buying houses in Suffolk County for over 26 years. We specialize in the Town of Brookhaven because we understand its unique challenges.

Size & Complexity

At 531 square miles, Brookhaven isn't simple. We know Rocky Point sells differently than Mastic, and we understand the 45+ minute drive from north to south.

Waterfront Expertise

We understand flood zones, FEMA maps, and storm damage on both the Long Island Sound (North) and Great South Bay (South).

Hamlet Knowledge

We don't use generic algorithms. We know property values hamlet by hamlet—from premium North Shore communities to affordable South Shore areas.

What Makes Us Different

We are not newcomers or out-of-state flippers. We live here, shop here, and value our reputation.

  • Same-day response & Zero pressure
  • Family-Owned Values (Speak directly to us)
  • Honest, Transparent Pricing (Open book math)
  • Licensed, Insured, Ethical Business
  • Property visit within 24-48 hours
  • We handle all paperwork & Closing costs
26 Years in Suffolk
50+ Hamlets Covered

What Happens Next?

1
Initial Call We discuss your property (5 mins)
2
Brief Visit We schedule a convenient time
3
Written Offer You get a cash offer in 24 hrs
4
You Decide Accept, decline, or negotiate

Ready to Sell Your Brookhaven House?

Get a fair cash offer in 24 hours. No obligation. No pressure.

Call Us Directly 516-605-3001 Speak with our team immediately
Get Offer Online Get My Cash Offer

Still have questions? Visit our Contact Page

Accessibility Toolbar

Signup to receive the latest offers and services.